Skip to main content


We got lemons so we decided to make lemonade (not a metaphor). I know you can do this by mixing lemon juice, sugar, and water, but I couldn't remember the ratio. I decided to search the web for "lemonade recipe". All the results had click-baitey titles, so I instead search for "simple lemonade recipe". First step of the first result: "to prevent the sugar from crystallizing at the bottom, start by making a simple syrup."

I hate the internet sometimes.

reshared this

@som_snytt I wish I had a lemon tree. I don't even have the land on which to grow one. 🙃
@silverwizard Sure. I'm just annoyed at how much SEO crap one has to wade through to find basic information sometimes.
@Jonathan Lamothe on one hand, yes
on the other take the risk you might need to add more sugar or drink overly sweet lemonade
@silverwizard @Jonathan Lamothe Lemonade is definitely a trial and error process, no online recipe can tell you how to enjoy it.

I have a cutting board with the message "Real Men Don't Use Recipes."

And it's surprising how good a glass of water with a squirt of lemon juice is. No sugar needed.

@Bob Jonkman I need recipes, at least the first time around to establish a baseline. I can sometimes improvise from there.

@bobjonkman I know you were airing a complaint and not requesting advice, and it is a grievance I feel deeply in my bones too...

...but would you like a truly kick-ass lemonade recipe?

Bob Jonkman reshared this.

@Ben Zanin Managed to find a decent one, but I'm not gonna say no.

@me the best lemonade I've ever made starts with oleo saccharum: the super volatile oils from the lemon peel, dissolved into and stabilized by sugar. The trick is to peel the lemons, weigh the peels, measure that same weight of granulated white sugar (*not* powdered, I'll get back to that), then use a cheap plastic bag vacuum sealer to jam the peel and sugar together. Leave it in the fridge for a day or two.

Juice the lemons, jar the juice, use the oleo saccharum as your sweetener.

1/3

@me You'll probably want to add some water after mixing the lemon juice and sugar; that step is up to your taste, and it'll depend on the tartness and sweetness of your lemons anyhow. You have a delightful opportunity at this step to use carbonated water if you like, though note that this seems to aerosolize some of the suspended lemon oils: you'll gain in aroma but lose just a touch in flavour. If you tend to garnish your lemonade adventurously this is another opportunity to embellish.

2/3

@me The thing about powdered sugar is that it should be finer and thus more aggressive about absorbing lemon oil, right? Except that most powdered sugar also has some anti-caking additives to offset how hydrophilic sugar is - often a powdered starch of some kind - and while it doesn't come through in baking, you'll taste it in your lemonade. Avoid my mistake!

https://www.bonappetit.com/story/lemoniest-lemonade-recipe

https://jeffreymorgenthaler.com/vacuum-seal-oleo-saccharum/

You'll never go back. It's everything you want lemonade to be. 💛🍋

3/3

@gnomon

Am definitely trying this the next time I get my hands on fresh lemons.

@me